Audit

Complete audit trail. 25 findings. 15 patches. 0 remaining.

Summary

25
Findings
25
Resolved
1
Critical
8
High

FORGE Findings (Code Quality)

F1HIGHhash.ts:36
Non-constant-time hash comparison
✓ RESOLVED — timingSafeEqual
F2HIGHserver.ts:18-31
Unbounded request body parsing
✓ RESOLVED — 100KB limit
F3MEDIUMtasks.ts:179-204
rejectTask bypasses validation framework
✓ RESOLVED — validateStatusTransition
F4MEDIUMserver.ts:54,69,87
endsWith routing is ambiguous
✓ RESOLVED — regex routing
F5MEDIUMserver.ts:44,60,75,93
as any casts defeat type safety
✓ RESOLVED — typed requires
F9MEDIUMledger.ts:23-37
No integrity check on load
✓ RESOLVED — verifyChain() on load
F10LOWserver.ts:143-145
Error silently swallowed in catch
✓ RESOLVED — console.error

SENTINEL Findings (Security)

S1HIGHserver.ts:18-31
No request body size limit
✓ RESOLVED — 100KB cap
S2HIGHtasks.ts:96,124,183
Agent authentication self-reported
✓ RESOLVED — Ed25519 signing
S3MEDIUMserver.ts:54,69,87
Fragile URL routing
✓ RESOLVED — regex
S4MEDIUMledger.ts:30-36
Silent ledger corruption on parse failure
✓ RESOLVED — throws on corrupt

LEDGE Findings (WORM Chain)

L1HIGHhash.ts:15
Concatenation collision in hash input
✓ RESOLVED — | delimiters
L2CRITICALworm/001_GENESIS.json
Genesis block hash mismatch
✓ RESOLVED — recomputed hash
L3HIGHledger.ts:18-36
WORM files disconnected from Ledger
✓ RESOLVED — integrated
L4MEDIUMledger.ts:88-130
No sequence monotonicity check
✓ RESOLVED — seq === i + 1
L5HIGHledger.ts:80-86
No file locking on persist()
✓ RESOLVED — FileLock class
L6MEDIUMledger.ts:33-35
Corrupt entries silently skipped
✓ RESOLVED — throws
L9LOWschemas/task.json:28
Schema enum mismatch (OPERATOR)
✓ RESOLVED — added OPERATOR
L10HIGHworm/*.json
WORM files lack atomicity/immutability
✓ RESOLVED — atomicAppend + chmod

AHMAD Axiom Review

SIMPLICITY_IS_VIOLENCE
PASS
"Remove until only truth remains."
No external dependencies. Only truth remains.
HUMANITY_BEFORE_FEATURE
PASS
"Does this serve a human need for accountability?"
Cryptographic proof of human accountability.
ENTROPY_IS_CATALYST
PASS
"Does the system handle chaos gracefully?"
File locks, atomic writes, chain verification.
ACCOUNTABLE_AUTHORITY
PASS
"Every agent signs its decisions. No impersonation."
Ed25519 non-repudiation. No self-reported identity.

Control Matrix

#ControlPhaseStatus
1Ed25519 per-agent signingPhase 1RESOLVED
2WORM sealed segmentsPhase 2RESOLVED
3Timestamp monotonicityPhase 2RESOLVED
4Startup halt on broken chainPhase 2RESOLVED
5File locking (PID-based)Phase 3RESOLVED
6Atomic writes (tmp→fsync→rename)Phase 3RESOLVED
7Body size limit (100KB)Phase 2RESOLVED
8Regex routingPhase 1RESOLVED
9Timing-safe comparisonPhase 1RESOLVED
10Hash delimiter (|)Phase 1RESOLVED
11Trust Deed formalizationPhase 4CREATED
12Task invariants formalizationPhase 4CREATED
13Ledger chain formalizationPhase 4CREATED
14AHMAD axiom reviewPhase 5PASS

Final Verdict

PRODUCTION APPROVED
v0.1.0-gauntlet · FROZEN · No proof. No deployment. No exceptions.

agent-farm-gauntlet v0.1.0-gauntlet · FROZEN

← Back to Home